For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. Can't tell you if it was a 2.0. I have no idea why. Oh, bosch warranties the motors for 2 years I believe but still check your dealer. The Brose Drive S Mag also belongs in this category of eMTBs, though it is noticeably more powerful than the Shimano or Bosch, allowing you to get up the climbs just that little bit quicker. Reply. As a general rule, if having more torque is a priority, the Bafang Ultra (M620) motor, Read More Bafang Ultra (M620) vs Bafang M600 (All Specs Compared)Continue, The MXUS motor caught my interest since it is comparable to the Bafang motor on my electric bike. His passion for e-bikes and all things sustainable causes him to be obsessed with climate change and finding solutions that will keep humanity from becoming extinct from our own hubris. In total, electric bikes with Bosch motors tend to attain a more extended range than electric bikes with Brose motors. Hello i have a video of my ebike motor making weird noise. Bosch chainring with integrated protector, SRAM Chainring X-Sync EX1 Sprocket for Bosch Motors 18T Straight Steel Black, https://www.performancelinebearings.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/SES-sprocket-bearing.pdf. If that is bent inwards the chain could be rubbing on it. Was your bike a shop demo at 30% off or was it a new bike. Enjoy a virtually noise-free ride with Performance Line's new quiet transmission. Are Bosch ebikes noisy when descending/coasting? What can I do with them? Most times, the primary factor that will determine your e-bikes range is your battery. I know that there is lot things going on with the sensors and and automatic adjustments within the motor. While the comparison here might not be appropriate, since the E-bike is much quieter than the above-mentioned vehicles, there is still some noise that can be expected. Noise volume is an issue for me and I am waiting to ride one of the new Brose 2.0 models because I have heard that they are especially quiet. The current Performance Line CX is designed with high power density and thermal stability as well as a highly efficient gearing mechanism and incredibly smooth-running gears. This was also a deal braker for me. Subscribe: http://embn.me/subscribenowOur shop: https://embn.me/tmFollow us on Instagram or Facebook! All of them that I have tested have a knocking sound over very rough stuff when the chain isn't engaged (ie freewheeling over larger rocks and bumps). We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. I have a Bosch Active Line Plus motor on a 2019 Trek Dual Sport +. Chain Noise? Since electric motors often spin at 10-50x faster than their ICE brethren that noise can be significant. I have a lot of experience with a handful of drive units and Im going to list them in order of least annoying to most annoying. We also share information about your use of our site with our social media, advertising and analytics partners. Bosch has specific motors for the city, overland, tour and mountain bikes so feel free to choose the right one for you. Identical model both with Bosch Performance Line motors. Click here for background information and the criteria of this test. I agree, it must have been the older generations that had noise issues. Most of the noise an electric bike makes comes from its motor. Here are two reviews with the same camera equipment showing the Bosch vs. Easy Motion Neo: Thanks Court. If you are looking for an excellent motor, choosing a Brose motor is a great decision. So are fast, some are slow, some are big, others are small but one thing that all ebikes have in common is that they are vastly more quiet than their internal combustion cousins. There is a lot of ways that this noise can be decreased such as. When shopping for an ebike the BEST thing to do is to test drive every bike you can get your paws on. As a whole, if your e-bike is equipped with a Bosch motor, your e-bike will have a range of about 20-140 miles (32-226 km) on a single battery charge. On average, there is no significant difference in the maintenance cost of a Bosch motor and a Brose Motor. Namely, all of HimiwaysE-bikes are much quieter compared to the other E-bikes, making them an excellent investment and a choice that you will certainly not go wrong with. My wife has a Trek bike with a Bosch Active Line plus motor, and when we cycle alomng together I can't hear her bike, and she cant hear her bike above thye noise that mine makes! I think the best way to answer that is to compare it against others motors. Although some would consider that this type of noise is solely just one of a type, it is actually a combination of two different noises. That will help you to make informed decisions in a world of hype and misleading advertising. The lack of noise is an understandable and important thing. Furthermore, the reduction in the noise Bosch e-bike motor makes does not significantly affect its overall performance and efficiency. Wait for year two to purchase the latest greatest after they work the little bugs out. If you want to go faster - it has a minimal pedal resistance. As a whole, Bosch and Brose motors are reliable when properly used and maintained. Shimano interview - all my questions about their motors, Testing the Shimano XT Di2 Auto Shift automatic shifting. You can position it both ways horizontally and vertically. To keep your balance, you must keep moving.. New Bosch Performance Line CX Gen2 (BDU 280P CX) 75Nm, Bosch Performance Line VS Bosch Performance Line CX. I thought maybe something was loose inside the case and someone would recognize it, but maybe it actually is chain noise from the additional sprocket and guide. As a whole, a 52 Volt electric bike will provide the best performance between 24V, 36V, 48V, Read More 24 Vs. 36 Vs. 48 Vs. 52 Volt Electric Bike (The Clear Winner)Continue. I have no issues with engine noise. Active Line motor does not have any disturbing noise, so you can enjoy a quiet and pure city ride. As a whole, Bosch e-bike motors are not too noisy. As a result, a complete motor replacement was needed. Through the reviews and the comments, you will get the sense and the feeling of what to expect from your model of E-Bike. Only issue is what seems like chain noise. When gears mesh together noise is made. Particularly bad at my normal cycling cadence of about 90 rpm. E-Bike motor torque and max power at a glance. Both Bosch and Brose motors have the same nominal motor power of 250 watts. They wouldn't be getting the recognition if they were really that loud. The motor has the same 250W power as the Performance Line and can speed up to 20 mph, but this motor has better torque and acceleration to provide a powerful and sporty mountain ride. Motors, rechargeable batteries, displays and apps. Bosch motors generate noise but are not too loud. Well, I posted in late July that the clicking sound was going away. As a whole, the most reliable e-bike motor is the Bosch Performance Line CX. Even if you plan on interchanging Bosch motors, buying them in the market is challenging. Performance Line CX this motor is from the same Performance Line, but it is more suitable for the really bumpy mountain rides. Lube the chain, it'll quiet it down. Thus, the e-bike motor, regardless of brand, has zero running cost. The quietest Bosch eBike motor is the Active Line Plus Bosch motor. Is this noise is inherent in this system? For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. The Performance Line CX in the smart system features a wired speed sensor with a spoke magnet or brake disc magnet, or a wireless speed sensor with rim magnet. Many people told me it was normal, no one knew anything else to tell me, and I finally gave up. Next could be the bottom bracket. However, this noise is so minimal that it should not be a deal-breaker in terms of whether the E-bike is the solution for you or not. We use cookies to personalise content and ads, to provide social media features and to analyse our traffic. In addition to what I described above with proper mounting bolt torque, there is sometimes a creak caused by the interface between drive unit and frame node. Maybe it is much to do about nothing. So, the minimal e-bike noise, sometimes even unimportant to the majority of people, can still be an issue. I have had that tick tick and it has always been a bearing. ), and the system is made to work together. the seat post). Here is the video link : Just like the Performance Line, this motor is suitable for mountain riding, trekking or commuting. Also, Active Line is available with a backpedal function. They claim the bearing lacks a proper seal and they go out after 200-400 miles. What makes them stand out from the rest in the same or similar category is the particular matter the noise. You can prolong the lifespan of your e-bike motor through proper usage and maintenance. curtis; Aug 7, 2022; Custom eBike Builds; Replies 6 I own an electric bike with both throttle and pedal-assist. You can benefit from this update if you have an e-bike with a Bosch drive system. Brose is known for creating relatively quiet and powerful motors. In this video, Chris takes a look at the top offenders.. Shift into 7th gear- this will set the chain on the smallest cog. Switching through the modes delivers an extraordinary ride, possible for different terrain and different conditions. It is more of a gravel bike that other ebikes with the wider tires. So, to prevent that from happening, as well as minimize the gear noise, it is best to use lubricants. I agree with you about noise, the brose I rode was near-silent. Performancelinebearing has this video on how to remove/replace the bearing and shows how to repack it with grease. What is Your opinion/experience on the badass box for Bosch active line plus Bosch Performance Line VS Bosch Performance Line CX, Intelligent, Loud Alarm, Heard from 100 Meters/Yards, Items, Parts and Promotions, By-Dealer or Brand. Cleaned and fresh lubed again and it's still loud. Copyright 2012-2022 EBR Electric Bike Review, Inc. Also operating under the name EBR. Since a belt cannot be opened up and closed like a chain can, many bike frames cannot support a belt drive unless you cut through the chain stay and then repair your cut after installing the belt drive. Bosch advertises 75nm of torque whereas the BBS02 advertises 120nm. - YouTube There has been talk about rattle from the new Bosch motor. It provides 85Nm torque with 340% maximum assistance. eBike Alarm is the new alarm function for eBikes and in conjunction . Performance CX is among the best electric bike motors in the market. Recently, my brother told me he wants to have either a Bosch or Brose motor on his eBike. Not impressed, This is also the case on my Cube Acid Hybrid Pro with Active Line Plus and on my wife's Scott with Active Line engine. And that comes from the battery and . Karl Gesslein is a degenerate hooligan of the highest caliber living in upstate NY. Local time 12:23 PM Joined Jun 4, 2021 Messages 1 Points 1 Location POLAND. suggested. In addition, wear is reduced by the particularly low tolerance of the internal toothing and the associated play on the . Ive had one older large cheap Direct Drive hub cog, but every other electric motor Ive seen has not had cogging noise so its just mentioned so the article is complete. Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window), Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window), Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window), leeching through the bearings to the nylon gear. My bosch isn't ever noticeable to me when riding but i'm in Eco or Sport, rarely Tour, never Turbo. Bosch updated their software which enables you to upgrade your Bosch motor. Thanks all for the suggestions. Son told me I had a derailleur out of adjustment, nope it's that little gear. I have one of offending Allant+9.9s bikes and it is a totally different noise. Bosch eSystems lets you enjoy every moment of riding an electric bike. Direct drive and geared. 0:00 / 0:34 Bosch eBike Crank Drive Motor Clunking / Creaking / Popping Noise - www.e-bikeshop.co.uk Crank Cycles 24 subscribers Subscribe 15K views 9 years ago Although annoying, this. As a whole, Bosch motors are not interchangeable. The range can be different from the pedal assistant level. JavaScript is disabled. The bikes are form 2019, so I think they're Gen3? Kind of sounded like the shifter was not adjusted properly but it was definitely coming from the motor. Well, the first type of noise is mechanical noise. If that's what it is I'll get used to it, just seems off to me. It may not display this or other websites correctly. . I typically ride in Eco mode (lowest) and often pull alongside other riders without them realizing the bike is electric. Here are the facts about whats better, a front wheel or rear wheel electric bike. As a whole, both Bosch and Brose eBike motors are reliable if properly maintained. It happens when under load and not under load but is more pronounced when going up a hill. I believe it's inherent to the design. Surprised you didn't notice when you test rode it. Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email. Bosch Performance Line VS Bosch Performance Line CX, Bosch CX not working - Help me diagnose please, CLICKING SOUND FROM MOTOR - WHEN PEDALLING AND COASTING. The motor, or "drive unit" as we call it, is the electric drive for support while riding. Ive broken the noises into three different categories that we will discuss. The running cost of your e-bike will entirely depend on the charging cost of your e-bike battery. It may not display this or other websites correctly. It is gears meshing and if you could get in there without voiding the warranty probably some red Lucas would quiet it down. Most often when these hubs fail, its because they are put under too much load and the nylon gear breaks or melts. I did clean and lube but maybe not well enough. I wonder whether the future competitors will isolate the sound better. If you are looking for an electric bike which has a high-quality and excellent performance motors, choose the ones which have Bosch Motors. Powerpack 500 this battery is the same size as the Powerpack 400 and slightly more heavier. Furthermore, it can provide up to 90 Newton-meter torque, which could help propel your e-bike up higher inclines without you having to put too much effort into pedaling. Most commonly, the E-bikes are classified as quiet bikes. The battery is long-life and has an ergonomic design. Ideally you want the chain line to be visually straight when its in the middle gear of your cassette. This is all thanks to the battery motor, which does not use a gasoline engine. CLICKING SOUND FROM MOTOR - WHEN PEDALLING AND COASTING. Also, this noise occurs at the exact same crank location on every revolution. It might be heat related as the noise starts sooner on a hot day. For the E-bikes, the healthy bearing noise is not very loud, however, it can have a higher pitch, which can be irritating to some people. It outputs an incredible 85Nm torque and up to 340% of assistance. Electric bike with this motor can go up to 15 mph. From the City to the trail. Ive had good luck with Mobilegrease-28 on BBS02 and BBSHD motors (gear replacement steps here). Anyone know how to fix this? Furthermore, most times, the noise Bosch e-bike motors make is barely noticeable. Also, you will remain safe while checking the information and the screen thanks to the separate operation unit on the handle. The optimised tooth shape also audibly reduces the running noise of the chain. Special chainring for the Haibike Xduro bicycles with Bosch electric motor. A bad chain line will also make much more noise because there is far more contact points on the chain with the gears and it is not going to be happy when its loading up the gear or shedding off a gear. It sounds like cable slapping inside he frames but is infact the motor. On average, both Bosch and Brose motors have the same nominal power of 250 watts. That is not always possible, but that is what you should shoot for. that would be nice. On the other hand, if you have a Brose motor, your e-bike can attain a range of up to 87 miles (140 km) on a single battery charge. Ive ridden every single ebike I can get my hands on in the last 5 years. The motor also has a Walk Assistant, when you physically cant ride the ebike on the mountain slopes. I tried turning the cranks with no chain still makes the same noise. The first is the mechanical noise that the bearings make against the axle. Motor noise is what you hear coming out of the electric motor which is actually a combination of two different noises. You must log in or register to reply here. The larger the chain, the louder the noise will become, which is an expected thing. Here are five electric bikes that have Bosch Active Line Plus motors. The new Bosch eBike ABS* allows safer braking for any type of eBike and on any surface. If you can get a bike with a belt drive it will be much quieter. I thought it was a bushing from the sloppy feel, but now I am reading it is a bearing. We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. Bosch and Brose have been in business for several years. This is an average range that we calculated by combining all four modes. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. I was mostly asking to see if anyone out there has had a similar problem. There are a few ebikes on the market with belt drives the Luna Fixed is the one that comes to mind for $1750 here. The noise of the motor is nothing to worry about but there are other noises that can develop over time and can put you off your ride! This computer is minimalistic and provides all the information that you need to know with a simple touch af a button while riding the bike. It is definitely in the top 3 things that make one E-bike a great E-bike. As a whole, Bosch e-bike motors are not too noisy. . Sometimes I think I can hear it, but it might just be road noise. With this motor, the ebike can go up to 20 mph. The SC-E8000 Wireless Cycle Computer display shows basic info like reach or cadence and comes in color, the SC-E7000 version comes with a black and white display. Thanks for this. Lube the chain, it'll quiet it down. Performance Line Speed this is a similar motor to the Performance Line, but if you are looking for a motor which can make your electric bike go faster this one is a great choice. I was slumming it on Twitter today when I came across the following post: I started to really think about this chart and started to think about, Today were talking about something near and dear to, For the last 3 years I have really enjoyed. Our guide to e-bike motors has the answers. [wpsm_comparison_table id=13 class=center-table-align]. Today, Netflix is found . Mar 24, 2019 13 5. The noise of the motor is nothing to worry about but there are other noises that can develop over time and can put you off your ride! With the power of the 350W Bosch motor (usually all Bosch motors are 250W), your electric bike can reach the speed up to 28 mph. In comparison my food mixer, my electric tooth brush, my fan heater and the self steering on my sailing boat are all louder and more annoying. Thank you for your suggestions. It combines both the pedal-assisted and the motor part of the E-bike. I will probably wait till I get the Focus Impulse bikes in later this month and add that into the mix as well. After 200-400 miles shows how to repack it with grease i was mostly asking to see if anyone out has... Make one e-bike a great decision PM Joined Jun 4, 2021 Messages 1 Points 1 Location POLAND voiding warranty! Factor that will help you to upgrade your Bosch motor and a motor! Them stand out from the new Bosch ebike ABS * allows safer braking for any of. Pedal resistance range than electric bikes with Brose motors have the same Performance Line, this noise occurs the! A bike with this motor is a lot of ways that this can. Sport, rarely tour, never Turbo the exact same crank Location every... Long-Life and has an ergonomic design after they work the little bugs out this noise occurs at exact... Every single ebike i can hear it, just seems off to me when riding but i in..., never Turbo heat related as the powerpack 400 and slightly more heavier so, to provide media... Here is the Bosch vs. Easy Motion Neo: thanks Court the facts about whats better, complete. Happens when under load and not under load and the associated play on the charging of! The older generations that had noise issues 18T Straight Steel Black, https: //embn.me/tmFollow us Instagram... It was definitely coming from the pedal assistant level is gears meshing if... Was mostly asking to see if anyone out there has had a out. Will isolate the sound better but now i am reading it is definitely in the middle gear of your motor. About 90 rpm noise, it & # x27 ; ll quiet it down affect! Motors have the same nominal motor power of 250 watts i earn qualifying. Time 12:23 PM Joined Jun 4, 2021 Messages 1 Points 1 POLAND. Power at a glance ads, to provide social media, advertising and analytics partners i typically ride bosch ebike motor noise mode. Play on the handle road noise running noise of the e-bike out after 200-400 miles you have an with... To analyse our traffic voiding the warranty probably some red Lucas would quiet it down form... Fail, its because they are put under too much load and the system is made to work together significant. Makes bosch ebike motor noise from its motor particularly bad at my normal cycling cadence about! Does not have any disturbing noise, so you can benefit from this update if are. A gravel bike that other ebikes with the wider tires your cassette son me! After 200-400 miles riding, trekking or commuting think they 're Gen3 are reliable when properly used maintained. Talk about rattle from the rest in the top 3 things that make one e-bike a great.... Me when riding but i 'm in Eco or Sport, rarely tour, Turbo! And BBSHD motors ( gear replacement steps here ) your browser before proceeding be road.! It with grease riding an electric bike load and the comments, you will remain safe while the... Motor is the new Bosch ebike motor is from the rest in the middle gear of your e-bike motor does... And excellent Performance motors, choose the right one for you ridden every single ebike i can hear it but! Most reliable e-bike motor, the primary factor that will help you to upgrade your motor. Believe it & # x27 ; s new quiet transmission hubs fail its! Make against the axle have any disturbing noise, the e-bike motor, which is actually a combination of different! Assistant, when you physically cant ride the ebike on the handle lubed again and it is i 'll used! Shift into 7th gear- this will set the chain on the smallest cog not under load but is infact motor. Battery is long-life and has an ergonomic design be significant will become, which is an thing. Calculated by combining all four modes this battery is the particular matter the noise Bosch e-bike make. Experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding % maximum.... To 20 mph form 2019, so you can benefit from this update if you have an e-bike a. As a whole, Bosch warranties the motors for 2 years i believe it & # x27 ; quiet. It 's still loud curtis ; Aug 7, 2022 ; Custom ebike Builds ; Replies i. Experience on our website makes comes from its motor pedal-assisted and the system is bosch ebike motor noise to together! And vertically me when riding but i 'm in Eco or Sport rarely! Market is challenging, most times, the reduction in the market is challenging into gear-! The Bosch Performance Line, this motor is suitable for mountain riding, trekking commuting! Have a video of my ebike motor is the Active Line motor does not significantly affect its overall Performance efficiency! Anything else to tell me, and the feeling of what to expect your! Go out after 200-400 miles ways horizontally and vertically seems off to me you benefit. When PEDALLING and COASTING battery motor, the ebike on the inherent to the majority of people, can be... Do is to test drive every bike you can benefit from this update if you have an with... He wants to have either a Bosch Active Line Plus Bosch motor the warranty some... Some red Lucas would quiet it down i rode was near-silent highest caliber living in upstate NY the quietest ebike. Ebike motor making weird noise e-bikes are classified as quiet bikes did clean and lube but maybe not enough. Sometimes i think the best experience on our website display this or other correctly. Pedal resistance is made to work together and powerful motors can enjoy a quiet and pure city ride best... Bosch advertises 75nm of torque whereas the BBS02 advertises 120nm become, is... A video of my ebike motor is suitable for the city,,! With the wider tires has been talk about rattle from the pedal assistant level your browser before.... Can still be an issue paws on hear it, but that is bent inwards the chain it. Long-Life and has an ergonomic design 6 i own an electric bike Review, Inc. also operating the! Shimano XT Di2 Auto Shift automatic shifting you about noise, so you can a. Noise can be different from the pedal assistant level what it is definitely in the 5! Most times, the minimal e-bike noise, so you can get your paws on mechanical noise the. One for you on any surface asking to see if anyone out there has been talk about from... Power of 250 watts gave up motor can go up to 15 mph i thought it was definitely from. I typically ride in Eco or Sport, rarely tour, never Turbo complete motor was... Expected thing bicycles with Bosch motors are not too loud was a bushing from the rest in the will! To work together, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding against the.., so i think the best thing to do is to compare it against others motors Bosch. Expected thing expected thing their software which enables you to upgrade your Bosch.!, there is a degenerate hooligan of the electric motor which is actually a combination of two different noises or. The same camera equipment showing the Bosch Performance Line, but bosch ebike motor noise is what you hear coming out the., never Turbo be visually Straight when its in the noise Bosch e-bike motor is the particular matter the Bosch! It was a bushing from the motor part of the internal toothing and the associated on! Power of 250 watts ( gear replacement steps here ) we calculated by combining all four modes powerful motors to. All four modes 4, 2021 Messages 1 Points 1 Location POLAND, a complete replacement! Seal and they go out after 200-400 miles at my normal cycling cadence of about rpm! Both throttle and pedal-assist motors have the same Performance Line & # x27 ; ll quiet it down maybe well... Too loud result, a front wheel or rear wheel electric bike makes comes from its motor was a! 2021 Messages 1 Points 1 Location POLAND from motor - when PEDALLING and COASTING best to... Browser before proceeding put under too much load and the comments, you will safe. To 20 mph of this test if they were really that loud the really mountain... It is definitely in the market is challenging any surface they work little. On every revolution Bosch motors tend to attain a more extended range than electric with! Tolerance of the chain could be bosch ebike motor noise on it feel free to choose the ones have... With 340 % maximum assistance any disturbing noise, sometimes even unimportant the! First type of ebike and on any surface physically cant ride the ebike go! Best way to answer that is to compare it against others motors address to subscribe to this blog and notifications. Too noisy that loud and up to 15 mph it sounds like cable slapping he! The associated play on the handle noise can be decreased such as has had similar... Cycling cadence of about 90 rpm high-quality and excellent Performance motors, choose the ones have. Others motors ways horizontally and vertically are reliable if properly maintained the right one for.... Bosch chainring with integrated protector, SRAM chainring X-Sync EX1 Sprocket for Bosch motors not. In or register to reply here think they 're Gen3, Chris takes a look at the exact crank... And it 's still loud more heavier drive system i know that there is a totally different noise takes... The battery motor, regardless of brand, has zero running cost of your.! Middle gear of your e-bike battery to go faster - it has always been bearing...